EU Forum


A perspective from the Sahel on the EU's migration policy

28 Nov 2016 - 14:30
Source: Oxfam International / Flickr

When states in the Sahel sign up to EU-designed ‘counter-migration’ border externalisation policies, they will have to define migration/smuggling as a criminal offence and organise repression. The consequences will be serious, given the perceptions of migration across West Africa, the value of migration for Niger as a transit country and the poor records of the Sahelian states in dealing with such transit flows.

Experts in the Sahel are sceptical the states will be capable of building the capacities needed for such a policy to ‘work’ – in the sense of stemming or containing migration flows – across the immensities of the Sahara Desert. At the same time the value of the migrant as a commodity will increase, meaning that investments and risk-taking will also increase. This will lead to greater pressures on state organisations, initiatives to open up new routes and, in Niger in particular, a reconfiguration of power relations in the northern desert with consequences and implications that are hard to predict.

In this note, I briefly examine the different points of apprehension stressed above and draw a conclusion on the Sahelian perception of the policy of border externalisation.

Migration: a deeply naturally rooted regional phenomenon

The factor to consider first is that West Africans do not see migration as a change of life and a permanent resettlement elsewhere – except when, like the Gambians, they are fleeing both poverty and a brutal despot. Migration is mostly practised within the region and to destinations within the African continent, and migrants are generally expected to return home once they have accumulated sufficient capital to become important people in their village, town or region. Communities and families being the primary fact of life for most West Africans, they very rarely conceptualise migration as moving permanently elsewhere to build a new life.

This idea of migration is held in the region not only by migrants, but also by people working around migration flows, to exploit and/or regulate them. There is, therefore, little to no interest in stopping migration in the region, especially since West Africa is the most open of the continent’s regional communities, with freedom to come and go established decades ago within the frameworks of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) and the West African Economic and Monetary Union (WAEMU).

As a result, a policy of border externalisation will not be accommodated in the region. It will not be approved by the culture and it will be seen as interfering with West African regional integration efforts. Given these negative odds, it will need aggressive means and practices of enforcement against both migrants and the lucrative networks of transport and assistance that have developed around an ‘activity’ which local populations view as perfectly natural.

Whenever state repression is imposed without the support of civil society, the repressed activity becomes more, not less, valuable. Repression will drive it underground, where the stakes will be higher, since people will have to fight the state to carry on. The apprehension here is that while state repression can reduce migrant flows by a significant margin, it will also increase violence at borders and on some migrant routes.

New routes will open beyond state control

A second apprehension is that new routes will be opened to dodge state control. This can happen in any number of ways with one potential consequence being that migrant routes will become less concentrated – as in the single large flow that now courses from southern Niger to Agadez and onwards. In such a case, more Nigerien communities will become involved in the migrant industry, rendering law enforcement more difficult from both a practical and political point of view.

The existing migrant industry is a stabilising factor

A third apprehension is the impact on Northern Niger, a region whose residents consider the migrant industry as the new stabilising factor after the demise of tourism. Border externalisation will imply a full dismantling of the industry in the region, with inevitable destabilising effects. Given the geopolitical environment – with terror groups still operating in neighbouring Mali and Libya and Tuareg irredentism still a serious issue in the region of Kidal, which borders Niger – the policy appears extremely risky, seen from the Sahel.

The context of a wider Saharan informal trade economy

Finally it should be borne in mind that migration in Niger is only part of a wider Saharan informal trade economy characterised by large-scale circulation/smuggling of consumer goods and illicit commodities, and meshing with state organisations at key junctures. This means that the policy of border externalisation will require serious reforms in how the state works in Northern Niger to be worth the cost. Such a proposition should be approached with the knowledge that Niger’s identity as a transit country dates back to the 1980s and derives from an ancient, pre-colonial pedigree as a ‘Saharan crossroads’.

To sum up, the policy will be unpopular for cultural and economic reasons; it will gravely interfere with West African regional integration; it will increase risks and violence associated with migration; it will have destabilising effects on Northern Niger; and it will need overdue but onerous structural reforms related to state organisations. As a result, border externalisation as a solution to the migrant issue is bound to be viewed in broadly negative terms in the region.

Rahmane Idrissa is the founder of Think Tank EPGA in Niger.


Load comments

link 8 jual baja h beam jual pipa boiler jual plat abrex 400 jual plat asme516 grade70 jual plat astm a285 c jual plat astm516 70 jual plat boiler jual plat hardox jual plat hb 400 jual plat high strenght jual plat high tensile sm490 yb… Pabrik besi beton jcac… Pabrik besi hollow… Pabrik besi hollow… Toko besi wf Toko besi unp undangan pernikahan batik Pabrik Bondek Cor… Pabrik Wiremesh Besi baja… Pabrik plat kapal besi baja… Pabrik besi beton interworld steel is… Distributor pipa besi… Distributor pipa besi… Toko wiremesh Toko besi siku undangan pernikahan murah Pabrik Atap Spandek Sni… Distributor Besi Siku Baja… Distributor besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton gunung garuda… Harga pipa besi… Harga pipa besi… Toko besi unp Toko Plat besi plat kapal undangan pernikahan online Pabrik Plat Bordes Kembang… Supplier Besi Siku Baja… Harga besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton delcoprima… Jual pipa besi… Jual pipa besi… Toko besi cnp Toko besi h beam baja undangan pernikahan anti mainstream Pabrik Plat Besi Hitam… Agen Besi Siku Baja… Jual besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton cakra steel cs… Supplier pipa besi… Supplier pipa besi Toko besi hollow Toko besi cnp undangan pernikahan cantik dan murah Pabrik Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel… Toko Besi Siku Baja… Supplier besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton bjku… Toko pipa besi… Toko pipa besi… Toko besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan unik Pabrik Jual Besi Siku Baja… Jual Besi Siku Baja… Toko besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton Sni Ulir Polos… Agen pipa besi… Agen pipa besi Supplier besi Wf Baja undangan pernikahan yang unik Pabrik Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal… Harga Besi Siku Baja… Agen besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton ais… Pabrik pipa besi… Pabrik pipa besi… Supplier stainless steel Supplier bondek undangan pernikahan lucu… Jual Besi Siku Baja… Toko besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton Sni Ulir Polos… Agen pipa besi… Agen pipa besi Supplier besi Wf Baja undangan pernikahan yang unik Pabrik Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal… Harga Besi Siku Baja… Agen besi siku baja… Pabrik besi beton ais… Pabrik pipa besi… Pabrik pipa besi… Supplier stainless steel Supplier bondek undangan pernikahan lucu Pabrik Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording… Pabrik Besi Siku Baja… Pabrik besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton… Distributor sch 40… Distributor sch 40 Supplier atap spandek Supplier wiremesh undangan pernikahan bunga Pabrik Besi Hollow… Distributor Besi Unp Baja… Distributor besi wf… Harga sch 40… Harga sch 40 Supplier baja ringan Supplier pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan islami

Wed, 04/03/2019 - 23:57


winterjas heren lacoste
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 20:23

In reply to by seoworking (not verified)


kunstkerstboom met sneeuw intratuin mode in meppel herenkleding <a href="">roze accessoires kleding</a> cei mai comozi balerini de dama din silicon paltoane copii la moda online pinkgirl <a href="… cazare turism 卯n cluj</a> sandale sport copii skechers relix ceasuri dama promotii. libertate 卯n fiecare <a href="… tratam hernia de disc fara operatie provita</a> husa personalizata pentru samsung galaxy s9 set echipament ronaldo real madrid sezon 2018 2019 4 15ani pantofi guess maro adidasi femei guess <a href="… de bucatarie diverse culori</a> portofel imperial horse piele
winterjas heren lacoste

umbro futsal street v boot ic
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 23:01

In reply to by seoworking (not verified)


<a href="… red north south reversible tote bag</a> easter dribble bibs john deere toddler kids elastic stretch hat <a href="… girls are obsessed with this practical coat trend</a> cherish luxury unisex baby gift pram hamper <a href="… love print couples t shirt men m red online. cheap</a> pillow blanket pink fleece john deere with pink minky <a href="… crunch is this weeks funko shop exclusive funko</a>
umbro futsal street v boot ic…

Thu, 04/04/2019 - 00:17


Thu, 04/04/2019 - 00:20


Thu, 04/04/2019 - 00:24


Sun, 07/14/2019 - 15:51

In reply to by seoworking (not verified)


<a href=" "> شراء الاثاث المستعمل بالمدينة المنورة </a>
<a href=" "> مكافحة حشرات بالمدينة المنورة </a>

<a href="…; شراء اثاث مستعمل بالرياض</a>

<a href="…; شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض</a>
<a href=" "> شركة مكافحة حشرات بجدة </a>
<a href="…; شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض </a>

Add new comment

Your name: Anonymous

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.