The consequences of our ‘No’

07 Apr 2016 - 18:41
Source: European Union 2016 - EP

At least 30 percent of the Dutch voters have cast their vote in the Ukraine referendum, and that the No camp has won with a vast majority.

With this result, the Netherlands is conveying some important messages. EU politicians have to deliver better EU policy, Ukraine should not act the victim, and EU issues demand EU-wide referenda, says Adriaan Schout (Clingendael).

‘No’ is not a reason for the Netherlands to feel guilty
The association agreement with Ukraine has been sparking heated debate between supporters and opponents. Both camps have inflated its significance. If the government acts on this ‘no’, legally speaking there will be no agreement between the EU and Ukraine.

The question is whether that will make much of a difference. According to the ‘no’ side that’s a good thing: Ukraine can continue to focus on trade with Russia and the EU is spared having to deal with a corrupt country. Nor does the ‘no’ camp believe the Netherlands has to answer to the EU or Ukraine over this. Those in favour, however, claim Ukraine’s progress will now be damaged, the Russian threat will increase, and the Maidan generation will lose its hope of establishing European values. According to the ‘yes’ camp, the Netherlands looks like a fool, because, just like with the European constitution in 2005, we have managed to ruin another European ambition.

Little effect
If the government acts on the ‘no’ vote, and supposing that, ultimately, there will be no association agreement, this will have little effect in practice. Too often in the past decades have we thought that EU policy would make the difference. Under the influence of the euro, South European countries would reform, but economic dynamism has failed to materialise while corruption and over-regulation in, for instance, Italy continue to proliferate.

Despite agreements and treaties, Europe’s external borders are still porous and Member States have often been incredibly slow to implement market legislation. With each crisis, countries prove to have great difficulty modernising, despite the many legal arrangements. Reforms affect existing power balances and economic relations and thus always meet with resistance. The fact that Greece is now finally reforming has little to do with treaties and agreements but simply with it being under supervision.

Modernising Ukraine
This association agreement would not have pulled Ukraine into the 21st century. Modernising is something that Ukrainians should mainly be doing themselves. It is up to the Ukrainian government, Ukrainian businesses and Ukrainian citizens to fight corruption and create trade opportunities. Ultimately, our ‘no’ has little to do with the choices the Ukrainians have to make themselves.

The European market is much bigger and more dynamic than the Russian one, and there is nothing stopping the Ukrainians to tailor their trade and values to the West. There is no reason for Ukraine to act the victim or say they have no longer a reason to reform now. If Ukraine chooses to modernise, neither the Netherlands nor the EU will abandon Ukraine. The EU will keep working towards trade liberalisation.

Reputational damage
Still, the Netherlands does have some explaining to do. The reputational damage will be far less as long as the Netherlands has a good story. There is no reason for us, just as there wasn’t in 2005, to be ashamed of this referendum. In the neighbouring countries they are also writing about the Ukraine agreement and similar views can be seen in the media there. In the United Kingdom, Brexit supporter Lord Owen calls the Ukraine agreement a dangerous example of European short-term thinking and in the German media the Dutch referendum is met with understanding.The Netherlands does not have a monopoly on doubts and primitive gut feelings about enlargement, on relations with Russia and on the preferred position of bordering country Ukraine.

The rejected agreement is a compromise between, mainly, Poland that wants enlargement and France that wants a trade agreement but not enlargement. That’s why it is more than a trade agreement but less than a political treaty. The EU has wanted to take things just one step too far and European politicians have insufficiently realised this. It is clear that the European negotiators should be better at assessing where the limits of European support lie; if not, the EU will be stumbling from one unsuccessful referendum to the next.

Referenda on EU policy will be taking place in more countries in the future. This referendum most likely does not make the Netherlands the EU-critical odd one out, but rather the forerunner in critically assessing European policy. ‘Yes’ would have been great, but this ‘no’ should be regarded constructively also by the rest of the EU.

The lesson that higher demands are now placed on the EU applies to all European politicians. They have to learn to be even less easily satisfied with the compromises they have to reach during the many difficult negotiations in Brussels. They should be better aware that at home different demands are made than in the Brussels arena.

It is moreover clear that if there will be more referenda, the instrument should be reviewed. One consequence of European integration is that issues that are clearly European require an EU-wide referendum. At the moment, with national referenda, any country may be the scapegoat. Besides, a national referendum generates political insights which later have to be shared EU-wide while the other countries may not be open to them.

Now that the EU is a political key issue Member States should also follow similar societal paths where EU subjects are concerned. There is no need for the Netherlands to feel guilty; but this ‘no’ does need a good European story.


Load comments

Howdy! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog.
Is it very difficult to set up your own blog? I'm not very techincal
but I can figure things out pretty fast. I'm thinking about
setting up my own but I'm not sure where to start.
Do you have any tips or suggestions? Thanks

Feel free to visit my web page ... <a href="">scr888 android and ios download</a>

Olivia Fonsi
Sat, 03/27/2021 - 13:25


Singer Mary J. Blige received a notice of Federal Tax Lien for $3.4 million that was filed in Bergen County Court back in February coming from the IRS.
The internal revenue service has also filed a tax lien in March in Westchester
where Blige owns the house. The IRS alleges that Blige has neglected to pay her required property
taxes for fat loss products . several long period.

Our bankruptcy laws are written so that secured creditors can feel safe that they will get
at a minimum something if the company get in to bankruptcy hearing.
Since secured creditors are taking lower risks,
they will cherish lower returns than unsecured creditors that not have this self-confidence.

I remember as a kid, thinking anyone over fifty was r-e-a-l-l-y former.

They all had white hair, and needed turn out to be helped next door.
Now in such a side of your coin, I scoff in the idea of not being mobile (though my knees do seem to be great barometers these days), and I've only found several white hairs .
so far.

"I disapprove of what you say, nevertheless i will defend to the death your right the man knows it." Should this apply to children who may even if
it's just know what they are saying? 3 remedies free speech case, Hazelwood School District v.
Kuhlmeier, 1988 the <a href="">scr888 agent topup</a> stressed
that students in public schools don't invariably have changing First Amendment rights as adults various other situations.

If an individual to go to the hospital, challenge into your market when obtain it.
Rise to the company office and negotiate it down. Can be a
sizable margin of wiggle room and own every in order to ask for doing it.

Most among the time, you'll have access to a
reduced cost without even an assertion. When they do argue, consider "no" to
answer. Climb the ladder of supervisors until you work with to the decision maker.

Solar energy panels behind the closed doors is a far nicer person willing on the internet a highly reduced hospital bill.

So I am aware some of yourself are still adjusting to being back at school.
But I'm here today because I have something in order to
discuss along with you. I'm here because I in order to be talk along with you about
your education and what's expected of you in this <a href="">scr888 new member bonus</a> school
same year.

It's necessary to remember that everybody has stuffs that are vital that them.
Or maybe even if it is not on your list of priorities, really hearing what others need can develop a big difference in the life of young children. And might have
designed a big difference for me today too.
I learned a lesson out of student. Sometimes you
need to ask for what you ask.

Olivia Fonsi
Wed, 03/31/2021 - 12:15


Add new comment

Your name: Anonymous

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.