EU Forum


The CSDP train leaves the station. So what?

07 Dec 2017 - 16:14
Source: Wikmedia Commons - NL Army Days

Anyone who has recently attended a security or defence conference is likely to have heard EU officials claim that more has been achieved in the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) in the last 12 months than in the previous 12 years. Following last month’s notification to the Council on Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO), a development described by High Representative Federica Mogherini as “probably the most important moment for European defence in decades,” she or he is also likely to have heard variations on the EU’s favourite metaphor: the defence train has left the station.

Certainly, there has been substantial movement on defence in the EU. The launch of three internal initiatives – PESCO, the Coordinated Annual Review of Defence (CARD) under the auspices of the European Defence Agency (EDA), and the Commission’s European Defence Action Plan (EDAP), which includes through the European Defence Fund (EDF) the prospect of EU funding for defence for the first time – together with a joint agreement at NATO’s Warsaw Summit on EU-NATO relations offer opportunities for real progress.

Praise for Estonia’s Presidency

Estonia, which currently holds the Presidency of the Council of the EU, has been justifiably praised for its defence agenda. Thrust into the driving seat six months early by the UK’s withdrawal from the rota, Estonia has shrewdly cast its Presidency as one in which key decisions would be taken. And in this, assisted by a refreshed Franco-German motor to drive things forward, the Estonians can claim success. In addition to the formal PESCO decision, which should be taken by the Council this month alongside the agreement of the first list of PESCO projects, the Estonian Presidency’s achievements are also likely to include the expansion of the Athena mechanism for financing the common costs of EU operations, and a Council position on the proposed regulation establishing the European Defence Industrial Development Programme.

The road to real progress in European defence

However, real progress in European defence will not be made in the taking of decisions, but in their implementation (which Estonia can happily leave in the hands of later Presidencies). The fact remains that despite the fanfares, the EU is not measurably closer to being able to meet its military level of ambition than it was when the Global Strategy was launched 18 months ago. The key requirement is for more European military capability. This in turn calls for more and better defence spending by the member states, as well as more cooperation between them. While cooperation is the watchword of the EU’s new defence initiatives, only the coming years will reveal whether these initiatives can motivate the member states to work more closely together; in other words, whether the EU can add value in a field in which accomplishments have been limited and largely due to bi- or mini-lateral, rather than EU-wide, arrangements.

On the face of it, the EU has not made a good start. The PESCO notification text is weak and has been roundly, and rightly, criticised by influential commentators. In the run-up to the launch of PESCO, much has been made of its legally binding nature, but this is only of value if the member states agree to be bound by things that will make a difference. A legally binding lowest common denominator agreement will be little, if at all, better than the entirely voluntary one that exists today.

PESCO: a starting point that can be built upon?

On the other hand, it is fair to note that the PESCO agreement is only a framework – a starting point that can be built upon. In managing the expectations of its stakeholders, the EU has done itself few favours in claiming success when all it is delivering is process. The list of PESCO projects to be published this month will offer better indications of PESCO’s prospects. To be credible, this list will need to contain new commitments, not just the rebadging of existing projects, and projects that will deliver capability to meet the EU’s long-recognised capability shortfalls, not just projects that enhance operational cooperation. Regrettably, early indications are that the projects to be put to the December Council will only partially meet these criteria.

It should also be recalled that PESCO is part of a package. There is a great deal of sense in the idea that requirements are identified by the EDA’s Capability Development Plan, that PESCO provides a framework for delivery of these requirements, that the EDF serves as financial underpinning, and that CARD provides a forum for review and corrective action.

Another measure of success, then, will be the extent to which this package works together. The EU institutions insist that cooperation among themselves is excellent, but the tendency of organisations to advance and protect their own interests at the expense of the greater good is well-documented. As an example, while it might have been sensible for an exclusive PESCO containing just a handful of member states to conduct a dedicated review process, it is questionable that a PESCO of (probably) 25 member states should require both an annual review of national implementation plans inside PESCO and a CARD process outside it. Some attention will need to be paid to this and other points at which the institutions rub against each other.

There will be other key tests of implementation too, for example the extent to which the review processes will be able to spotlight the performance of individual member states, rather than the collective performance that less enthusiastic individual states can hide behind (note here that the only quantified commitments in the PESCO notification are annotated “collective benchmark”) and the degree to which the industrial interests of the smaller member states can be satisfied by the EDAP. Frustratingly, 19 years since the EU defence dimension was launched at St Malo, it is still too early to know if this venture can succeed.

Towards a meaningful destination

It does not matter if the defence train has left the station. What matters is that those on board find the will to ensure it reaches a meaningful destination soon, rather than endlessly circling the same tracks.

Tony Lawrence is a Research Fellow at the International Centre for Defence and Security, Tallinn, Estonia. The views expressed here are his own.


Load comments

amazon 濂炽伄瀛?銈广偗銉笺儷姘寸潃 銉兂銉斻兗銈?銈儑銈c儉銈?adidas
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 21:00


<a href="… magista onda ii dynamic fit ag pro yeni sezon bayan</a> lager 157 basic har ni eloise de 浜烘皸 sobre 銈姐儢銉?銈儯銉愩偣銉笺儎 銈儯銉?銈广兗銉?澶с亶銇?<a href="…偙銉笺偢銉с兂銉夈儸銈?銈汇儍銉堛偄銉冦儣銈掔潃銇撱仾銇濄亞 titivate</a> ml574 lha 銈炽儛銉儓銈般儶銉笺兂 銈兗銈?銈兂銉戙兂銉炪兂 锝傦絺銆€锝侊綈锝嶏紤锛橈綍銆€銉欍儞銉笺€€瀛愪緵銆€闃插瘨銆€闀烽澊銆€銉偆銉炽儢銉笺儎銆€銈儯銉┿偗銈裤兗 闈淬伄銈儶銈搞兂 <a href="…儑銈c兗銈广伄鎵嬭 銉儍銉?璧よ壊绯?銉曘偂銉冦偡銉с兂閫氳博 zozotown</a> 銉€銉笺偡銉?銉儱銉冦偗銈点儍銈?a4銈点偆銈?16008 jewelna rose 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銈炽兂銉愩兗銈?銈兗銉偣銈裤兗 銉┿偆銉?ox銇€氳博 <a href="…鍒嗐仹鎲с倢銇?銇忋伋銈?銇屽嚭鐝?銇撱伄澶?姘寸潃銇屻偔銉炪倠 鍐欑湡</a> 銈汇偗銈枫兗姘寸潃 銉兂銉斻兗銈?銇勩仭銇旀焺銆€銉儑銈c兗銈广€€ 浣撳瀷銈儛銉?銉戙儍銉変粯銇?m
[url=… 濂炽伄瀛?銈广偗銉笺儷姘寸潃 銉兂銉斻兗銈?銈儑銈c儉銈?adidas[/url]

shopping online bambini blocchi di costruzione per bambini
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 21:08


zapatillas mujer calzado zapatillas nike air max 97 black <a href="… extra grandes ruedas de lona plegable bolsa de</a> suelo blando para bebes de segunda mano por 12 en vitoria <a href="… accesorios viaje equipaje maleta cubierta</a> marcas de falda a media pierna topshop nude spot button <a href="">pant… gucci hombre</a> kohuijoo oto帽o mujer camisa de manga larga vestido blanco <a href="… cazadora vaquera ancha desgastada plus negro piel</a> verano sexy de ba帽o bikini boxer traje de ba帽o de los
[url=… online bambini blocchi di costruzione per bambini[/url]

nylon to the bone augusti 2017
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 21:17


<a href="…?銈搞儯銉笺偢 涓婁笅 銉儑銈c兗銈?nike 銈点偆銉夈儵銈ゃ兂 s m l xl xxl 瑁忋儓銉偝銉冦儓 銉堛儸銉笺儖銉炽偘銈︺偋銈?鍗婇浠ヤ笅 銈偊銉堛儸銉冦儓</a> 銉愩儍銈?銉°兗銈兗 銉°兂銈?klasyczna elegancka bluzka damska 50 <a href="… uomo gioielli cesare paciotti ace 24</a> colourful dreams collection of gala dresses papilio p艂aszcze puchowe w kolorze bia艂ym w sklepie quiosque <a href="… air max muse erkek gri spor ayakkab谋 en</a> gizli topuklu 7 cm. boy uzatan ayakkab谋 <a href="… white snubn铆 prsteny s ru膷n铆m ryt铆m brilas wedding</a> morellato collana da uomo gioielli
nylon to the bone augusti 2017

adidas superstar unisex 36 45 aras谋 t眉m numaralar谋
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 21:54


carall lampada torcia led officina ricaricabile snodabile <a href="… bluzka z cekinami</a> kurt dds trekking erkek bot mavi 41 yaz ocuk prenses sandalet kristal papyon <a href="… waikiki erkek mont yelek</a> boyner nike super academy futbol ayakkab谋s谋 bu mudur coach 銈炽兗銉?闀疯病甯?璧?vans 銉愩兂銈?銈儯銉冦儣 銉°儍銈枫儱銈儯銉冦儣 cap beach girl truc au wowma 銉偊銉?<a href="…€銆€銉┿偊銉炽儔銉曘偂銈广儕銉笺€€闀疯病甯冦€€杩峰僵鏌勩€€銉°兂銈恒€€銉儑銈c兗銈广€€澶с亶銈併€€銈点偆銉曘€€锝愶綊锝侊絼锝併€€2锝?220銆€銉曘偂銈广儕銉间粯銆€ 涓彜 銉栥儵銉炽儑銈c兗銉ソ澶╁競鍫村簵</a> <a href="… 鐒″湴 銉嬨儍銉堛儻銉炽償銉笺偣 銉欍兗銈枫儍銈?銈裤偆銉?/a>
[url=… superstar unisex 36 45 aras谋 t眉m numaralar谋[/url]

诇讬讙转 讛讗诇讜驻讜转 讛讙专诇转 砖诪讬谞讬转 讛讙诪专
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 21:58


<a href="… brand plus size woodstock graphic tee</a> <a href="… in hoodie and glasses hanging head down stock photo</a> <a href="… ariat ladies coral white theresa cold shoulder top</a> <a href="… women ladies winter black red plaid pleated ball gown</a>
[url=… 讛讗诇讜驻讜转 讛讙专诇转 砖诪讬谞讬转 讛讙诪专[/url]

seksi 15 cm y眉ksek topuklu sandalet gece kul眉b眉 dans
Wed, 03/11/2020 - 22:47


妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 绲愬寮?銇婂懠銇般倢 銈点兂銉€銉?銉儑銈c兗銈归澊 闈淬伄閫氳博 babydoll鏂扮敓鍏愭湇60cm銈汇儍銉?銉曘儶銉炪偄銉椼儶 銉┿偗銉?<a href="…?銈枫儱銉笺偤 銈搞儱銉嬨偄 銈偡銉冦偗銈广伄閫氳博 au wowma</a> 銉娿偆銈?nike 銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銈ㄣ偄 銈搞儳銉笺儉銉?3 銉儓銉?air jordan tak谋m elbise ceketi siyah <a href="">kurtka adidas tech</a> pin p氓 t酶j til store piger 銈炽兗銉?銉忋儻銈?銈广儶銉冦儩銉?銉偒銈枫兂銇€氳博 1鐐?<a href="… 銉€銉炽偗 銈广儖銉笺偒銉?dunk hi pro sb 銉€銉炽偗 銉忋偆 銉椼儹 銈ㄣ偣銉撱兗 305050 337 銈般儶銉笺兂 銉°兂銈?zzi 杩斿搧涓嶅彲</a> 銉欍兗銈广儨銉笺儷銈儯銉冦儣銇ㄣ伅 銇嬨伓銈婃柟 銈炽兗銉?閬搞伋鏂广伄鍩虹 妤藉ぉ甯傚牬 銈搞儳銉笺儉銉?銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銉儑銈c兗銈归澊 <a href="… 銈ゃ偞銉笺儷 igor 銈儍銈恒偟銉炽儉銉?銉炪偢銉冦偗銉嗐兗銉?/a>
[url=… 15 cm y眉ksek topuklu sandalet gece kul眉b眉 dans[/url]

jeans cremallera trasera
Thu, 03/12/2020 - 00:46


<a href="… 28 讗讬谞抓 诪讞讬专</a> <a href="… de ni帽os baratas marca compara 17 productos y compra</a> <a href="… gt fuji 500mile race fourth consecutive victory for</a> <a href="… 65 de descuento hollister hollister hco hombre</a>
[url=]jeans cremallera trasera[/url] pour moi swimwear women clothing
Thu, 03/12/2020 - 00:50


<a href="… off empire waist lace skirted tankini set</a> vilebrequin vilebrequin mens moorea fish print swim trunks de manera atractivo abrigos y chaquetas de bombardero <a href="… de fiesta colecci贸n 2014 entrenovias</a> <a href="… beauty case maleta multiusos tipo trolley malet铆n</a> kohuijoo oto帽o mujer camisa de manga larga vestido blanco ba帽ador speedo essential endurance 7cm ba帽adores nataci贸n <a href="">… de bebe para bodas</a> chaqueta vaquera para mujer oto帽o invierno talla grande pour moi swimwear women clothing…

cream gina dress
Thu, 03/12/2020 - 01:02


adidas x 16.1 fg tam prof letoon gkm 01t erkek krampon <a href="… x uo backpack h谩tizs谩k h谩tizs谩k</a> ozdoby choinkowe dzieci buffalo classic銉椼儵銉冦儓銉曘偐銉笺儬銈广儖銉笺偒銉?銉曘儶銉炪偄銉椼儶 銉┿偗銉?furla 銉忋兂銉夈儛銉冦偘 銉戙偆銉戙兗 榛?銉偠銉?<a href="… lip service wban 334000</a> <a href="…偡銉冦偗銈?銉欍儞銉笺偡銉ャ兗銈?2瓒?銈点偆銈?3.5銈汇兂銉?銈汇儍銉堛仹銇?/a> <a href="…︺亰銇嶃仧銇?瀹夊叏闈淬伄浜烘皸銉°兗銈兗 銉栥儵銉炽儔涓€瑕?/a> 銈儍銉堛偨銉?闀疯 銉儑銈c兗銈?銈枫兗銈广儷銉?銉堛儍銉椼偣 銈枫偄銉?t銈枫儯銉?銉儑銈c兗銈?闀疯 鐒″湴 t銈枫儯銉?钖勬墜 銈儶銈搞儕銉? <a href="… a 3 fili nei 3 colori delloro con palline diamantate</a> br枚llopskl盲nning strandbr枚llop kurtka puchowa ea7 emporio armani <a href="… donna acciaio doppia catena gold con cristalli sunlight breil</a> 銈嗐仯銇熴倞瑁俱偪銉冦偗銉併儱銉嬨儍銈儻銉炽償 <a href="…仾銈夈仹銇伄鐫€銇撱仾銇椼倰 鐧姐偣銉嬨兗銈兗 澶т汉銇椿鐢ㄨ 銉°兂銈?/a> siyah spor giyim 莽ekici kad谋n gri zemin 眉zerinde beyaz k眉p <a href="… bor铆t茅kt谩ska fekete univerz谩lis m茅ret</a>
[url=]cream gina dress[/url]

Add new comment

Your name: Anonymous

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.