EU Forum


European defence in the French elections

19 Apr 2017 - 15:33
Source: ResoluteSupportMedia / Flickr

Keep calm and carry on or keep calm and get out

Defence has gained a prominent place in the debates for the presidential elections. Although not without precedent, this topic has rarely been so central as nowadays. The reasons underpinning this phenomenon are numerous.

First, France is engaged in various highly visible military operations including the Barkhane operation in the Sahel, the Sentinelle operation on the mainland, and airstrikes in Iraq and Syria. Second, the security environment is very volatile with the threat posed by terrorism and the resurgence of Russia, putting military matters under the limelight.

Finally, the main candidates disagree on how to manage France’s alliances, be it the EU with the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) or NATO. On this point, candidates converge in the assertion that France does not get enough support from its European allies. This thinking is not new but once more significant now that Donald Trump has become the U.S. president. However, whoever wins the election has no crystal-clear plan about how to steer European defence forward.

What the candidates propose
The French elections are monitored very carefully abroad. The outcome has rarely, if ever, looked so unpredictable only days before the first round. Four candidates indeed find themselves so close in the polls that all four can realistically aim to be in the second round. Among them, Marine Le Pen and Jean-Luc Mélenchon are openly questioning the relevance of belonging to the European Union and to NATO. Nervousness across Europe is therefore understandable considering France’s political, diplomatic and military weight in Europe.

François Fillon and Emmanuel Macron – not to mention Benoît Hamon, although his chances to stand in the second round are slim – would reassure French partners when it comes to Paris’s commitment to European defence. They differ on which method to favour but they agree that more efforts are necessary at the European level.

François Fillon has repeatedly emphasised the importance of strong bilateral relations with the United Kingdom – regardless of Brexit – and Germany. He also advocates “a European alliance of defence” although he has not clarified what that would entail. It would likely resemble the situation that Europe is in today with an additional push for cooperation when it comes to mutualising the costs of military operations and supporting European defence’s technological and industrial base. One certainty is that it would not give additional prerogatives to centralised institutions.

None of the candidates has a crystal-clear plan about how to steer European defence forward

Emmanuel Macron would strictly follow in François Hollande’s footsteps. He would set a European defence fund, which already exists; an operational HQ, which seems a more likely prospect nowadays; a European security council, which has already been widely debated; and the establishment of a permanent structured cooperation, the principles of which have already been initiated by Paris and Berlin. This is not surprising since Macron has garnered the support of Jean-Yves Le Drian, France’s current Defence Minister, but it also reveals a lack of direction over what to do as far as European defence is concerned.

NATO: not in the centre of French attention
In the French traditional thinking on “L’Europe de la Défense”, the EU takes precedence over NATO. Very little air time has been devoted to the Atlantic Alliance. François Fillon and Emmanuel Macron find it useful but there is no central role for NATO in their defence policy. On the opposing side, Marine Le Pen and Jean-Luc Mélenchon are long-time critics of NATO, which they consider subjugated by Washington. An exit from the Atlantic Alliance would therefore enable France to regain its full sovereignty, according to them.

On top of the French traditional stress on the EU, the context helps to grasp why the Alliance finds no traction in the defence debates. The uncertainty brought forward by President Trump’s evident indifference as far as Europe is concerned does not serve the interests of the transatlantic relationship. Donald Trump’s arrival in the Oval Office has generated two types of reactions in Europe. Some countries have been anxious to explain to the new President how essential the U.S. is to European security, while others consider disengagement by the U.S. as an opportunity to build a stronger European security architecture. France clearly belongs to this second camp – and this feeling is shared across the political spectrum.

Defence has been extensively addressed and debates have on occasions offered their lot of renewed thinking. European defence has not benefitted from the same treatment. All candidates revert to ideas which have been floating around for quite some time, whether they imply more of the same or a rush toward the exit. For the sake of European defence, the mainstream politicians among the candidates offer a more conventional route, which would not disrupt on-going efforts, but they would not really inject fresh thinking either.

Vivien Pertusot is an Associate Researcher at the French Institute of International Relations (Ifri). He tweets at @VPertusot.

This article is published with the support of the Adessium Foundation.





Load comments

Alex Brown
Sun, 04/21/2019 - 20:08


Paris that's right it's 2019 and that means it's almost time for another World Cup. What better place to talk about it than the city that FIFA was founded. We are and we are here to tell you everything you need to know about the FIFA Women's World Cup.

Rohit Singh
Thu, 04/25/2019 - 11:16


Very Nice Gifts For Mother's Day 2019. Gifts for Working Mom, Personalized Mother's Day Gifts 2019. Get Here.
<a href="">NNNOW Coupons</a>
<a href="">SUGAR Cosmetics Coupons</a>
<a href="">Mothers Day Gifts</a>
<a href="… Minute Mother's Day Gifts</a>

The Trustworthy Dubai Escorts girl. I really understand the value of your needs and dreams so expect the most excellent escorts services in Dubai
The heavenly moments that you had in with us will remain unforgettable in your life,

Rohit Singh
Mon, 04/29/2019 - 00:23


Very Well Written Content Nice Post Keep Posting Like This. I am Going to share your content on social media platforms.
<a href="">Copa America 2019 Schedule</a>
<a href="">ICC Cricket World Cup 2019 schedule</a>
<a href="">Copa America 2019 Live Streaming</a>
<a href="">Icc Cricket World Cup 2019 Live Streaming</a>

Cricket World Cup 2019 Free Live Streaming
Thu, 05/02/2019 - 12:04


Great thoughts and i love the idea presented in the article. Thank you sharing the thought as i find it really very helpful.
I have found a website that provides all information related to the Cricket World Cup. i got a lot to know from that platform. You can also visit and read
<a href="… World Cup 2019 Live Telecast Channels</a>
<a href="… World Cup 2019 Schedule Download</a>
<a href="… Cricket World Cup 2019 Schedule PDF</a>
<a href="… Cup Schedule time table</a>
<a href="… cricket world cup teams</a>
<a href="… Cricket Team Bowling Coach</a>

niicholas smith
Tue, 05/07/2019 - 07:00


TNT and CBS will offer live coverage of the PGA Championship throughout the championship. Here are the TV times for both TNT and CBS:
Featured groups are also available to stream for free through B/R Live which is available on web, iOS, Android, Apple TV, Amazon FireTV and Roku.

Add new comment

Your name: Anonymous

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.