The Wilders effect on European mainstream policies

28 Mar 2017 - 12:04
Source: Flickr / Metropolico.org

Rather fuelling the anti-establishment trend than an EU domino effect.

The extent to which Wilders’ ‘success’ (i.e. not winning the Dutch elections but emerging as the largest opposition party in a politically fragmented Netherlands) has an impact on European mainstream policies depends on a variety of factors, i.e. the existing Dutch discourse, the transferability of ‘the Wilders’ effect’ to the unique contexts of other member states, and the interactions between them.

First of all, the explicit anti-EU campaign Wilders launched from 2011 onwards should be seen in the context of an already existing Dutch dynamic since ‘Maastricht’, when the traditional goals of the instrumentally pro-EU Dutch governments were achieved with the completion of the single market. Dutch interests no longer necessarily aligned with European interests; in 1999 the Dutch campaigned for a rebate, in 2002 the government firmly expressed allegiance to the subsidiarity principle, and after the failed constitutional treaty of 2004 mainstream parties’ language gradually shifted from ‘EU integration’ to ‘European cooperation’. Wilders’ role was thus raising the stake, particularly during the economic crisis, which severely tested the traditional Dutch stance of an EU based on rules to prevent deeper integration. Prime minister Rutte for instance made the (broken) promise during the 2012 elections to send no more money to Greece.

While Dutch rhetoric partly changed, the Dutch stance generally did not. Successive governments have – reluctant or not – remained loyal to the European mainstream while trying to maintain the traditional Dutch line in a EU of 27/28 where compromise is unavoidable. In addition, Wilders is (now) excluded from government, the EU is hardly (and intentionally not) a voting issue and support for EU membership remains high in the Netherlands. Nevertheless, Wilders’ relatively large party will stand ready to criticise the EU whenever, due to new events, it becomes controversial for direct national interests. Moreover, whereas the attitude towards the EU of the next government is supposed not to differ substantially from that of its predecessors, the image of an increasing gap between rhetoric and reality with future EU compromises could linger. This will fuel anti-establishment sentiments and political fragmentation that may damage EU policies in the long run.

On a side note, the rise in the last elections of the progressive parties D66 and the Dutch Greens who are pro-federal EU (but the major defeat of the traditional left) is not necessarily positive. As it is currently unclear whether their new voters actually did, or the broader electorate will, support them for their EU positions.

With regard to the impact Wilders potentially has in the rest of Europe; he might be a specific inspiration for the AfD (Germans in particular share the same EU sensitivities with the Dutch) who will pull some of the rhetoric in Germany, in particular that of the CSU. Overall, however, Wilders primarily fuels the general shift in political contestation from a ‘left’ versus ‘right’ to a new ‘open’ versus ‘closed’ society political paradigm (e.g. the liberal party of Germany criticises the ECB and calls for a Grexit, but is not necessarily popular). How this precisely impacts European policies in each member state could differ, taking into account individual country factors, sensitivities and histories.

In countries like the Czech Republic, Poland and Hungary strong EU friction already emerged earlier on with Vaclav Klaus (2003-2013), PiS (2005-2007) and Viktor Orban (since 2010). Wilders’ showing might add to (renewed) feelings that the (current) EU is not a solution but a problem. Yet, in Spain prime-minister Rajoy, who was responsible for the painful ‘EU reforms’ during the crisis, recently got re-elected, and in Austria, pro-European candidate Van der Bellen won the presidential elections while his opponent Hofer had already disavowed the idea of leaving the EU. After everything, the Euro also still remains popular in Greece, with a pro-European reformer, Kyriakos Mitostakis, as would-be replacement of Tsipras. Germany, like the Netherlands, is predicted to more or less maintain the status quo on EU policies with a new grand coalition after the elections. France, with the two ‘outsiders’ Le Pen and Macron currently competing, is a clear case of the newly emerged political paradigm. It could revolutionise the French political system while at the same time a status quo/pro-EU stance is a likely outcome. Italy is a case of more severe political instability, but in practice not necessarily one of radical EU change (the Five Star movement is unlikely to govern while it does not even endorse a EU or Euro exit and even flirted with the ALDE group).  Nevertheless, with an increasing blurry line between national and European politics, the EU can definitely suffer collateral damage through the spread of anti-establishment sentiments such as those advocated by Wilders.

Lastly, (other) unique interactions between member states are equally important. Ironically, ‘pro-EU’ sentiments in one member state might hypothetically spur ‘anti-EU’ sentiments in another, and vice versa. For example, if France and Germany would agree to take major steps forward in European integration concerning economic governance, Dutch governments might have a hard time trying to sell Europe at home. On the other hand, EU frustration with ‘weak’ and ‘untrustworthy’ member states, for example in Germany and the Netherlands, that forcefully encourages a multi-speed Europe could turn the Visegrad states – already weary that the concept might de facto undo enlargement – surprisingly more ‘pro-EU’ (despite anti-EU rhetoric in the region, no serious party advocates leaving the EU and the extreme right in Hungary even proposes a ‘wage union’).

In sum, Wilders’ ‘success’ primarily fuels the anti-establishment trend, while a direct EU domino effect, if there ever was one, has been halted with the last Dutch elections. Nevertheless, in the absence of a clear European narrative that mainstream parties can (or will) sell to their voters (while simultaneously sustaining their mainstream EU positions which includes compromises that go against direct national interests), they will remain vulnerable to anti-establishment politicians who, any moment the EU becomes a topical issue, will exploit it in a newly emerged political contestation of ‘open’ versus ‘closed’ societies.  

282 Comments

Load comments

There’s no denying that Chaturbate, BongaCams, and LiveJasmin are some of the greatest cam sites of all time. They are similar in different ways.<a href="https://www.livesexking.com/">cam girls</a> You get to see free shows and can jerk off without spending a dime. However, if you do buy a token or two, your curiosity is rewarded. Comparing free to private shows is like comparing Chaturbate to the old sex cam sites. We thought they are good until we’ve tried alternatives. [url=https://www.livesexking.com/]https://www.livesexking.com/[/url] https://www.livesexking.com

best free vpn download
Tue, 07/28/2020 - 08:19

Permalink

In the past few years, the popularity of <a href="https://www.freevpndetective.com/">best free vpn download</a> has steadily increased, but for obvious reasons, this growth rate will accelerate sharply by 2020 and more and more people want to work and play at home. Is free VPN the answer? And if so, where should you go? [url=https://www.freevpndetective.com/]https://www.freevpndetective.com/[/url] https://www.freevpndetective.com

Plastic inflatable dolls came about in 1968, when it became legal to sell <a href="https://www.sexdolls.today/">sex toys</a> via mail. By the 1980s, they were in sex shops. With the continual development of Artificial intelligence , the level of companionship has entered a new realm where the entire landscape of sexual toys < a href=" ">https://www.sexdolls.today/</ a> [url=https://www.sexdolls.today/]https://www.sexdolls.today/[/url] https://www.sexdolls.today

car insurance
Fri, 08/07/2020 - 10:41

Permalink

Plastic inflatable dolls came about in 1968, when it became legal to sell <a href="https://www.carinsurancestars.com/">car insurance</a> via mail. By the 1980s, they were in sex shops. With the continual development of Artificial intelligence , the level of companionship has entered a new realm where the entire landscape of sexual toys <a href=https://www.carinsurancestars.com/>car insurance</a>[url=https://www.sexdolls.today/]https://www.sexdolls.today/[/url] https://www.sexdolls.today

Plastic inflatable dolls came about in 1968, when it became legal to sell <a href="https://www.sexdolls.today/">sex toys</a> via mail. By the 1980s, they were in sex shops. With the continual development of Artificial intelligence , the level of companionship has entered a new realm where the entire landscape of sexual toys < a href=" ">https://www.sexdolls.today/</ a> [url=https://www.sexdolls.today/]https://www.sexdolls.today/[/url] https://www.sexdolls.today

dental insurance
Fri, 08/14/2020 - 09:29

Permalink

The preferred insurance plan for your <a href="https://www.dentalinsuranceguides.com/">dental insurance</a> should not just save money but also provide you peace of mind, with the knowledge that you’ll be covered as needed. Your smile and teeth rely on regular visits to your dentist, and a solid dental insurance plan will ensure your teeth stay white for years to come. [url=https://www.dentalinsuranceguides.com/]https://www.dentalinsuranceguide…] https://www.dentalinsuranceguides.com

Management Writing Help
Fri, 08/14/2020 - 12:54

Permalink

Management courses are highly specialized courses and particularly designed to impart essential management skills in a student. So, by design, in a management course a student should first learn how to manage multiple assignments at the same time to get good grades in each of the courses. We have a team of experts committed to helping students to manage multiple assignments in <a href="http://theessayassignmenthelp.com">Management Writing Help</a> courses. Most of our experts have substantial industry experience and are highly skilled in terms of handling assignments in different specializations of any management courses. Our experts highly value the time line provided for any assignments and deliver the solution well within that.

Economics Essay Writing Help
Fri, 08/14/2020 - 12:54

Permalink

Our experts cover macroeconomics, microeconomics, managerial economics, international economics and as complex subjects as climate change economics essay assignment, advanced econometrics assignment, and so on.
With our dedicated Economics assignment help team for distinct sub-topics, we ensure that your assignment fulfils all the assignment requirements. So, stringently following the marking rubric, our experts are well-versed with the complexity of the assignment required as well as the referencing style required to be used in your essay. All the experts are experienced professionals who have had decade-long industrial experience in helping students with all their academic requirements. So, once you hand over your essay requirements to our <a href="http://theessayassignmenthelp.com">Economics Essay Writing Help</a>, you can be rest assured to get HD grades.
Along with essays, our economics team is well-equipped and proficient to provide you economics research papers, dissertations, theses, or any other economics assignment help as per your request.

Add new comment

Your name: Anonymous

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.