How the Dutch fell out of love with the EU

09 Mar 2017 - 09:36
Source: Carnegie Europe

There is something up with the Dutch. As one of the six founding members of what became the European Union, the Netherlands claims a special place in the European family. Some even say that through Benelux—a system of political and economic cooperation between Belgium, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg that started with a customs agreement in 1944—the Dutch helped inspire Europe’s integration project. But increasingly, they appear grumpy and disappointed with the EU. 

Among its European peers, the Netherlands is a middle-tier power with middle-of-the-road politics. Belief in European cooperation is strong, though successive Dutch governments have steered away from promoting a federal Europe. The political establishment is pro-EU, but also staunchly Atlanticist. Mainstream thinking on commerce and trade is Anglo-Saxon, the approach to finance and monetary policy is German, and the social welfare system is similar to those of Denmark and Sweden.

The Netherlands is too small to be considered a threat, but large enough to be taken seriously: with 17 million inhabitants, it might be called the largest of the small EU member states. Thanks to a domestic political system that nurtures coalitions and compromise, the Dutch are respected in Brussels for their pragmatism, common sense, and consensus building. These ingredients have helped the Netherlands become an attractive and influential coalition partner.

Strategically, the Netherlands has worked to maintain a balance in the EU: among the large countries, and among the institutions. It enthusiastically promoted British membership of the European Community in the 1970s to balance against Franco-German dominance. And it saw a strong European Commission as a way to keep large member states in check and promote the interests of smaller ones.

On foreign policy, the Netherlands favors strong international engagement but rarely takes a controversial position. The country wants a strong EU in international affairs to amplify its own bilateral foreign policy and address issues for which it does not have the bandwidth by itself. But it wants the European External Action Service to coordinate European foreign policies, not direct them. The Hague has been ambitious on European defense cooperation, particularly by integrating its military forces and capabilities with those of Germany and Belgium; but like most other EU members, the Netherlands has dramatically cut its defense budget in previous years.

As an Atlanticist, free-trading nation, the Netherlands backed the negotiations on the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP), though antitrade protests made the government lukewarm about a deal. Even on Russia, it supports the EU’s sanctions regime, but less fanatically than might be expected of a country that lost 193 of its citizens when Russian-backed separatists shot down Malaysian Airlines flight 17 over eastern Ukraine in July 2014.

But since the early 2000s, the Netherlands’ image as a mainstream, no-nonsense partner has changed: the Dutch have started to view the EU with growing suspicion. EU enlargement in 2004 altered the union’s internal balance and member states’ voting weights. The Netherlands has less of a say than some of the newest members, yet it is one of the largest per-capita contributors to the EU budget. Despite the benefits in mutual trade, a larger union meant the Dutch voice became softer. This proved particularly uncomfortable when member states agreed to hand over more powers to Brussels.

Meanwhile, the commission proved unable to stop some countries from breaking EU rules such as the Stability and Growth Pact, which aims to ensure economic stability, sparking the ire of the rule-abiding Dutch. A first sign of estrangement was the rejection in a 2005 referendum of the EU’s proposed constitutional treaty.

The eurozone crisis added further concerns about the EU’s direction of travel: the Netherlands became a creditor country that was asked to bail out Southern eurozone members while having to take their word for it that they would make the reforms necessary to weather the financial storm. The perception that the Dutch were left paying the bill while other countries flouted the rules became fertile ground for Euroskeptic politicians. It boosted the anti-immigrant, anti-EU popularity of Geert Wilders and made the Dutch government increasingly critical of the commission and ever-closer EU cooperation. The government saw the commission less as the defender of small countries’ interests and more as an overly ambitious regulator with an appetite to expand its reach.

By 2013, The Hague was actively seeking a smaller, more effective commission and finding support in Germany and other member states. Former Dutch foreign minister Frans Timmermans introduced a subsidiarity test to identify policy areas that can better be left to member states than to the commission. Later, as first vice president of the commission in charge of the better regulation portfolio, among other issues, he supported a mantra that “the EU should be big on big things and small on small things.”

Gradually, however, public opposition to the EU hardened. The rejection of the EU Association Agreement with Ukraine in a referendum in April 2016 underlined the image of the Netherlands as a country critical of the EU. Today, support for EU membership hovers at around 40 percent, feeding speculation that the Netherlands could be next to leave the club after Britain voted to quit in June 2016.

Euroskeptic parties will do well in the parliamentary election on March 15, even though a referendum on the Netherlands’ EU membership is unlikely for now. Brexit helps Dutch Euroskeptics in another way than just setting a precedent that could be copied. Britain’s decision creates a financial headache for The Hague, as it will be under pressure to help fill the €10 billion ($10.5 billion) annual funding gap the UK will leave behind in the EU budget.

Brexit will also make it more difficult for countries to block decisions in the EU Council under the union’s voting rules. To stop France and Germany from pushing a decision through, a blocking minority of thirteen member states is needed. The EU’s new arithmetic puts smaller (and Northern) states at a disadvantage.

The Dutch government seeks a more pragmatic European Union, not a federalist fairy tale. In response to Brexit, some European leaders now talk of a flight forward toward deeper integration. But the Dutch law that enabled a referendum to block the EU-Ukraine Association Agreement could similarly be used to block a new EU treaty. And so, as long as that law exists, The Hague will oppose changes to the treaties.

It is unclear whether the governing coalition that emerges from the March 15 election will have the political courage to change the law. Much will also depend on the new balance of power in the 27 remaining EU member states. It remains to be seen whether the Netherlands can ensure that its interests are protected and its concerns heard in a union that will inevitably revolve around Berlin and Paris. For the time being, the Dutch feel they are being pushed—albeit reluctantly—ever closer to the exit.

Rem Korteweg is a senior research fellow at the Centre for European Reform in London and starting April 1 at the Clingendael Institute.


Load comments

What i don't realize is in reality how you are
not actually a lot more neatly-favored than you may be right now.
You're very intelligent. You realize therefore considerably
in terms of this matter, produced me for my part believe it from numerous various angles.
Its like women and men don't seem to be fascinated until it is
something to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your personal stuffs excellent.
At all times maintain it up!

my website - bitcoin dice (<a href="">Helen</a&gt;)

Pune independent escorts
Sat, 01/30/2021 - 13:38


Gurgaon escorts
Wed, 02/03/2021 - 04:16


Our organization is a definitive goal where all scopes of appealing ladies looking for men in Gurgaon are accessible to go to your exceptional love wants. About female escorts, it isn't simply they are in this calling to meet your sexual needs, yet they are likewise prepared to go with you to any business occasion too. To serve you with an extraordinary administration is the assurance we give and to achieve them our escorts in Gurgaon are accessible day in and day out. We are proud to the point that our tip top young ladies are brilliant, erotic and self-autonomous. Regardless of whether it is a business occasion, selective gathering or a private visit, you can don't hesitate to enlist your most loved young lady for in-get or out-call dates from our organization.

VIP Gurgaon Female Escorts Gives You Physical Intimacy
Wed, 02/03/2021 - 05:26


Book or take a meeting with the best VIP Gurgaon female escorts, we would constantly open entryways for you to give magnificent sexual administrations both at our place and at your place. A lovely and hot female model escort in Gurgaon from will make a point to get superb experience. When you book an escort young lady from us, we will ask every one of your dreams ahead of time, so we will ensure you get the best dreams from the best world class escort young ladies in Gurgaon. We give best desi hot young ladies, wedded lady, remote models, understudies, and scope of young ladies which suits to your dreams. In the event that you truly need to in your life, taste once our administrations throughout your life, and perceive how it would be?

preeti jain
Wed, 02/03/2021 - 05:53


Escorts in Gurgaon Truly, you heard it right, our overly model and autonomous Gurgaon escort young ladies are at your administration on your interest. You might mull over about the results of enlisting these young ladies. Give us a chance to give you finish thought regarding our Gurgaon escorts administrations. We are making a total universe of satisfaction for our customers. We will begin with feature the reason we are here in this calling and what this Gurgaon escorts is about. Responsibility to convey you top class and veritable administrations is the main motivation behind why we are #1 escort organization in Gurgaon.

miss rekha
Wed, 02/03/2021 - 06:23


Flirting, being friends or very good friends and going out on a special date with a girl all are very different situations from proposing a girl. Men who are going to propose a Gurgaon Escorts Girl should do this with utmost care. It hurts very much to get denial after proposing a girl. When it comes to proposing Girls, men need to take several factors in to account. Here is a short guide to help you know the best way to propose a Gurgaon Escorts. This is exactly why they can ensure you the sort of complete satisfaction that not only fulfills you essentially yet additionally holistically.

Add new comment

Your name: Anonymous

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.