EU Forum

Social Europe

The V4 lack a shared vision for Social Europe

14 Nov 2017 - 13:38
Source: Kancelaria Premiera / Flickr

The Visegrád Group (V4) has lately been in the European spotlight. This once peripheral, regional alliance suddenly proved capable of single-cause impromptu mobilisation within the EU-framework. In the middle of the so-called ‘refugee crisis’ it actively resisted the European Commission on relocation quotas. How sustainable is this new capacity and how can it affect the European Union? The opportunity to tackle these questions presents itself again due to the emerging debate on European social and labour policies.

Czechia, Hungary, Poland, and Slovakia joined the EU in 2004. Nevertheless, they are still called ‘new member states’ as the long-awaited convergence of wages, living standards, and access to social services never fully materialized. What did happen was mass emigration, especially from Poland and Hungary, causing a so-called brain-drain of the economically active population and putting national social-security systems in jeopardy.

At the same time, competitive advantage in the region has mostly been gained through a cheap and qualified labour force, tax exemptions, and more flexible labour rights. As a result, the economic strategy that makes the V4 countries attractive for business is simultaneously holding them hostage in the middle-income trap. Building a solid welfare state could change that, but other political interests outweigh social concerns. For example, in January 2017, the European Parliament voted on a resolution on the Pillar of Social Rights, prepared by the centre-left Socialists & Democrats group. In the plenary vote, the vast majority of MEPs from the V4 countries were against it, even though the proposals for strengthening labour rights were restricted to the Eurozone.

The economic strategy that makes the V4 countries  attractive for business is simultaneously holding them hostage in the middle-income trap

This attitude is in line with the initial discontent of some Eastern European states with the initiative to reform the posted workers’ directive. Emmanuel Macron’s ‘divide and rule’ strategy in approaching only the chosen Eastern member states while by-passing the hardliners, like Poland and Hungary, paid off. He won the backing of Slovakia and Czechia as well as Romania’s and Bulgaria’s readiness to seek compromises on the contested regulation.

Nevertheless, from the perspective of some member states, coordination of social policy at the European level is still perceived as harmful. In their view, harmonisation of labour regulations or introduction of common European social transfers could lead to the loss of their competitive advantage or increase their budget deficit. In other words, social policy is by some still considered an expense, not an investment.

Special V4-meeting in Warsaw
In March 2017, shortly after the White Paper on the future of European Union by Jean-Claude Juncker had been published, a special meeting of V4 leaders was held in Warsaw. They agreed that the values on which the EU is based remain valid and one should strictly avoid any kind of disintegration of the single market, the Schengen area and the European Union itself. It is evident that Poland, Czechia, Slovakia and Hungary are not in favour of federalisation, but a return to the single-market-only model does not seem satisfying either.

The conclusion is that the V4 needs Europe, but is incapable of delivering any constructive visions. The Group is not even institutionalized in the sense of a formal administration and embraces many contradicting interests. There are some fundamental differences between the dogmatic collision course of the Polish government and Hungary’s pragmatic approach towards the EU, symbolically embodied in Victor Orban’s support for Donald Tusk as President of the European Council.

Poland appears to be losing its leading position in the V4, while Slovakia would be the readiest to break out from the group

Even if the impression of the ‘troublesome’ V4 was strengthened by Poland and Hungary, the Czech and Slovak attitudes towards the EU are not alike. In particular Slovakia significantly advanced integration with the EU by joining the Eurozone in 2009. Initially the poorest of all V4 countries, today it’s one of the world’s leading car manufacturers per capita, drawing direct foreign investments mostly from Germany, France and Asia. The internal dynamics of the V4 will now change again, after the centrist-populist Ano party has won the elections in Czechia.

Individual interests within V4 tip the balance in debate over Social Europe
Today, the Visegrád Group seems dependent on immediate political circumstances and individual interests will therefore most likely tip the balance in the debate over ‘Social Europe’. Poland, the biggest and lately the most confrontational country of the region, seems to be losing its leading position. Slovakia (which) would be the readiest to break out from the Group, not keen on being “left behind” if the multi-speed scenario for Europe gains traction.

When it comes to others, the flexibility of Orban and Andrej Babiš, likely the next Czech prime minister, will allow them to treat the V4 in a rather opportunistic way, uniting to seek favourable trade-offs and reach satisfying, ad hoc deals.

Generally speaking, the upheaval of the social pillar could become a tangible proof of the EU’s value and purpose after years of ‘polycrisis’. However, there are hurdles on the way, not only of an institutional or structural character. There is a profound lack of consent what the EU should look like in the future and which principles it should follow. What for some comes across as a “betrayal of the European spirit”, others consider to be free and fair competition. On top of that, recent failures in managing the migration influx has lowered public confidence in European institutions. Thus, the coordination of social policy within the Community seems as complex as necessary a task for years to come.

Dr. Maria Skóra is the Senior Project Manager at the Berlin-based think tank Das Progressive Zentrum .
 

160 Comments

Load comments

I can make a commitment, that if we get a majority in this election, we will follow up, right away, with actions that match the scale of our challenges.BTW visit https://essaysworld.net/ site which will help u solve your writing problems.

Nathan William
Tue, 04/30/2019 - 12:03

Permalink

Engineers who wish to migrate to Australia must submit a Competency Demonstration Report and the Engineers Australia must approve it. Thus, engineering students look forward to getting CDR help Australia which assists them to get a flawless CDR. This reduces the chances of rejection by the EA.
Most students and experienced civil engineers are today looking forward to migrating to Australia as the job scope is better and bigger with a high pay scale. Therefore, getting CDR help is the only scope to gain entry into the country.
The CDR for Engineers Australia must be impressive and abide by the ANZSCO code and guidelines. It should also showcase the skills of the applicants as a suitable civil engineer to work according to the Australian rules and regulations.
The service providers who assist the students with CDR have experienced CDR report writers. These writers know the requirements of a CDR and do it accordingly. Visit-
https://myassignmenthelp.com/au/cdr/

Jin Seth
Mon, 01/20/2020 - 01:14

In reply to by Nathan William (not verified)

Permalink

The Statistics Assignment Help was created with the vision to provide an ideal online resource for Statistics Assignment/ Homework, Advanced Statistics Project Help, Exam Preparation Help and Online Tutoring. After going through our detailed, step by step solutions, there was a difference in the way students think and approach problems. It was our urge and compelling desire to aspire always for perfection which enabled our students to achieve excellent grades in Assignment/Homework help.
https://www.thestatisticsassignmenthelp.com/homework-help

Mike
Mon, 01/20/2020 - 13:01

In reply to by Nathan William (not verified)

Permalink

MATLAB or Matrix Laboratory is a fourth-generation programming language that operates in multi-paradigm numerical computing environment. MATLAB was developed by The Mathworks Inc and was primarily intended for the purpose of numerical computing. However, this application can be used to access symbolic computations by adding the optional toolbox of MuPAD symbolic engine. In addition, our Matlab assignment help experts also give you proficient idea about Simulink that is a significant part of MATLAB that introduces designs of multi-domain simulation for embedded and dynamic systems. You can avail MATLAB assignment help if you counter any type of assignment writing problems.
https://allassignmentexperts.com/matlab-assignment-help

Jose
Sat, 02/01/2020 - 09:39

In reply to by Nathan William (not verified)

Permalink

www.theprogrammingassignmenthelp.com is the World’s Best Online Assignment help, Academic Homework Help and writing assistance web provider that prides itself in being the best online assignment help website for students around the world. Many students enrolled in even the best degree programs internationally in best colleges and universities are often unable to grapple the pressures of multiple homework submissions, clashing deadlines, tight semester schedules as well as managing mid-term and end semester examinations with submissions of high quality research essays, term papers, homework problem sets and other university writing requirements. As a result, students either submit a low-quality UML Diagram research writing essay, UML Diagram homework problem set and college assignments, leading to low grades or they simply choose to skip the submissions, which can often extend their course completion timeframes.
All of these pressures and inability to cope with academic deadlines, assignment and homework submissions lead to mental stress and destroys all the hard work that students put in all through the academic year in keeping up with the unsurmountable coursework. It is in times like this that most students wish there was a service that would “Make My Assignment” “Do My Assignment” “Help Me with My Assignment” “Last Minute Assignment Help”. https://www.theprogrammingassignmenthelp.com/uml-diagram-assignment-help is precisely the solution to all these students’ problems. Whether you are a student of PreK-12 school grades or studying in a college degree program or enrolled in a graduate school and research programs at Master’s level or are a doctoral or postdoctoral research student, each student can benefit immensely from taking services of Assignment Help Online. At www.theprogrammingassignmenthelp.com we cater to various categories of academic assistance provisions such as Online Assignment Help, Academic Essay Writing and Editing Services, Dissertation assistance services, UML Diagram Programming assignment help, UML Diagram Case Study Writing Help, Homework Help, Custom Coursework Help, Research Writing help, GhostWriting Services, Thesis help, Help with CDR writing and many more academic writing assistance services such as proofreading, plagiarism check and removal, referencing check and proper referencing generator.
https://www.theprogrammingassignmenthelp.com/uml-diagram-assignment-help
#DoUMLDiagramAssignment #HomeworkHelpUSA #UMLDiagramHomeworkHelp #UMLDiagramassignmentexperts #AssignmentHelpUSA #assignmenthelpUK #UMLDiagramAssignmenthelp #UMLDiagramHelp #assignmenthelpcanada #HomeworkHelpAustralia #HomeworkHelpCanada #UMLDiagramHelpMalaysia #AsisgnmentHelpUAE #HomeworkHelpUAE

Rachel Braun
Tue, 05/07/2019 - 16:58

Permalink

I realy like to read informative post and your post is that of kind, moreover it is the similar topic as my topic for the college essay which now is conducted by a proffesional writers at https://essaysempire.com/

Add new comment

Your name: Anonymous

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.